What Great Leaders Know About Learning
What managers must do in a new era to keep their best people
by David Newman
Another key employee has just quit. When asked why, she immediately responds that her manager was hard to get along with, gave conflicting priorities, and could be moody, often snapping when a staff member made a minor mistake. “I love the company” she says mournfully, “I…I just can’t work with him anymore - not one more day.”
That’s the least of your worries right now. You’re working on several big sales opportunities, and you need to be closing them. You just won several new pieces of business that require your adding head count or looking to outside contractors, as your people are now stretched too thin. You want to refinance a loan to upgrade to some much-needed equipment. You have Excedrin headache #113 and it’s tax time, so your bookkeeper and accountant need a lot of your attention these days. Welcome to business reality. Developing your managers isn’t exactly your top priority right now, is it? It a nice to have not a have to have, right?
Well you are completely and totally Wrong. (That’s with a capital W.)
According to a recent Gallup poll, people don’t leave companies, they leave managers. How much is turnover costing you? How much time and money does it cost to recruit new people, train them and get them productive? More than you think.
One of our clients in the restaurant industry (not a high-paying field, generally speaking) sat down and did the numbers on our two-page Cost of Turnover worksheet and figured out that for each of the 20 employees that left her company over the last 12 months, the hard and soft costs totaled $70,000 per employee!. That’s right – over $1.4 million total.
According to estimates by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), without doing any complicated math, it costs between 1.5 and 2 times an employees’ salary to replace them. Then multiply by the number of people that leave you each year and you can see that it would cost a lot less time, money, and effort to fine-tune the skills of your present managers.
Here are some ideas:
1. Understand the consequences of inaction. Yes, you can continue to skate by for a while. But how long have you been skating by already? Are you close to a major meltdown and don’t know it? When it comes, it will take much more time and money – and headaches -- than you imagined. The general manager of a manufacturing plant fired over a dozen people in his first year on the job. Why? Because previous inaction on his predecessor’s part was simply too expensive in lost sales, poor service, and low morale on the part of people who saw the laggards skating by. Having poor managers is like not replacing your oil filter - as the saying goes, “You can pay me now or pay me more later.”
2. Realize it will take some time and effort. It will be lots of work on your part to start an effective program and start to turn your leadership culture around. Sustainable progress is not about sending managers to one-day courses. This needs to be an ongoing process, not just an “every once in a while” event when you can fit it in. The good news: Companies that managed their culture well far outdistanced those that didn’t in John Kotter and James Heskett’s landmark study documented in their book, Corporate Culture and Performance. Specifically, the companies that consistently paid attention to their leadership culture over time enjoyed:
- Revenue increases of 682% vs. 166%
- Stock price increases of 901% vs. 74%
- Net income increases of 756% vs. 1%
- Job growth of 282% vs. 36%
So the bottom line (in case we’ve been too subtle so far) is that management development doesn’t cost you money; it makes money in translated performance.
3. Work with an internal or external professional learning consultant. They understand how long-term change happens and can design a plan that will ensure measurable results. A good mix will include a needs assessment, some seminar time, one-on-one coaching, peer support, follow-up, and performance measurement. Another critical factor is demonstrated management commitment to change (i.e. CEO buy-in, senior management attendance, involvement, and yes, maybe the long-overdue firings of some “bad apples.”)
4. Start something. To quote Mick Jagger – “Start me up!” Yes, even if the plan is not fully fleshed out. Sure, it would be great if all of the pieces of the puzzle were in place before you begin. Yet, if 80%-90% of the plan is in place, that’s good enough to launch! Use Tom Peters’ words of advice, “Ready, Fire, Aim!” After all, development is a dynamic endeavor. You’ll be tweaking and modifying it as you go, anyway. Your people will come up with ideas of what they want added and changed to make it even more effective for them. Your program needs to become their program. Involvement and engagement are the keys to buy-in and results.
After reading these four points, have you gotten turned off? Are you saying “Wait a minute - my people aren’t that bad.” (The heads of many defunct companies felt the same way.) But the real question is do they have the skills to step up to the next level of responsibility? Are they regularly growing and learning how to be better at their job? And can you really afford to be complacent about developing your future leaders? Remember your organization has to be BETTER every year to stay up with the competition nipping at your heels.
The same Gallup poll found that one of the reasons top employees leave is that they feel they are not learning and growing, or that no one took an interest in their development.
Start getting development for your people and take an interest in their growth. Just like your teeth and your customers, if you ignore your employees, they WILL go away.